书籍 Disgraceful Matters的封面

Disgraceful Matters

Janet M. Theiss

出版时间

2005-01-09

ISBN

9780520240339

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍

Looking beyond the familiar trappings of the cult of female chastity—such as hagiographies of widows and chastity shrines--in late imperial China, this book explores the cult's political significance and practical ramifications in everyday life during the eighteenth century. In the first full-length study of the subject, Janet Theiss examines a vast number of laws, legal cases, regulations, and policies to illustrate the social and political processes through which female virtue was defined, enforced, and contested. Along the way, she provides rich details of social life and cultural practices among ordinary Chinese people through narratives of criminal cases of sexual assault, harassment, adultery, and domestic violence.

Janet M. Theiss is Associate Professor of History at the University of Utah

用户评论
有个moral responsibility转移到妇女个人趋向。女性在法律案件中常常反对父母和宗族和儒家礼教的定义,对父系社会的原则产生挑战。国家希望定义正确的思想和行为。但在司法实践中,贞女自己的定义却往往受到尊重与确认。
Agency in female suicide
messiness in court cases of female chastity
和Sommer放在一起读非常有意思。因为和Sommer的出发点不同,在解读材料时比Sommer大胆也冒险很多。以及,Susan Mann奶奶的review真厉害,不动声色又一针见血地点出了这书的方法、逻辑漏洞。
与材料结合紧密导致无法滑水读完。除了最后一章最后两节有点牵强以外,剩余的分析做得很漂亮,各方势力轮流登场。在谈Female chstity中诸多contradiction和negotiation时,似乎隐约在回应Ko:gender orthodoxy中的漏洞在民间不会带来resilience而是致命的conflict和fracture。
思路相当混乱的一本书。
主线似乎是国家对个人道德义务的鼓励与强调会反过来削弱父权秩序的稳固性,线索是不错,但是点题的地方似乎不多(妇女自杀问题给帝国高层带来的两难矛盾;宗族处理性别纠纷时经常息事宁人导致事主越级上诉,处理捉奸问题时的法律关怀重心放在婚姻而非代际关系上),另外就是最后的结论感觉也走得离谱了
问题主要在于中央的案件都是死刑案件,所以激烈程度非比寻常,所以作者指出的不少矛盾具体剧烈程度其实不太好说
skim and scan; 对我来说最有用的部分还是她在intro对于chastity scholarship的总结/susan mann的书评还提到了这个主题的开山鼻祖mark elvin's classic analysis of female virtue and the state/ "Female virtue and the state in China"(1984)
chap5